Archive for the ‘Schools’ Category

Transgender Athletes in Sports: Litigation Trends and Insurance

Overview: A Contentious and Evolving Debate

The question of whether transgender athletes—particularly transgender girls (biological males identifying as female)—should be allowed to compete in female athletic divisions remains one of the most contentious legal and cultural battles in America. The conversation has intensified in youth and college athletics, where it intersects with federal law, school policy, athletic integrity, and insurance risk.
As of 2025, the debate has shifted sharply in favor of biological female protections, driven by federal enforcement actions under the Trump administration and growing institutional pressure on colleges, sports organizations, and insurers.

Legal Landscape: Key Court Cases and SCOTUS Review

From 2020 to early 2024, federal courts largely ruled in favor of transgender athletes:
  • West Virginia v. B.P.J. (2024): The Fourth Circuit ruled that excluding a transgender girl from school sports violated Title IX and the Equal Protection Clause.
  • Luc Esquivel v. Tennessee Board of Education: A federal district court found a transgender boy’s exclusion from boys’ sports unconstitutional.
These decisions remain in force, but the U.S. Supreme Court has agreed to hear both the B.P.J. and Little v. Hecox (Idaho) cases during the 2025–2026 term. Final rulings expected in 2026 may set a national precedent.

Federal-Level Policy Reversals Favoring Biological Females

Recent executive orders and enforcement actions have triggered a dramatic shift in the legal balance:
  • Executive Order 14168 (2025): Redefined “sex” in all federal civil rights guidance as binary and assigned at birth, excluding gender identity from Title IX protections.
  • Executive Order 14201: Titled “Keeping Men Out of Women’s Sports,” this order directed the Department of Education and Department of Justice to require all federally funded institutions to prohibit biological males from participating in women’s sports.
Notable enforcement outcomes include:
  • University of Pennsylvania (Lia Thomas case):
    • The Department of Education forced UPenn to retroactively strip Lia Thomas of her NCAA titles.
    • Medals and records were reassigned to biological female competitors.
    • The school was required to issue public apologies and amend eligibility rules to comply with the executive order.
  • NCAA compliance:
  • U.S. Olympic & Paralympic Committee (USOPC):
    • Adopted similar policies barring transgender women from female categories.
    • National governing bodies were instructed to enforce sex-assigned-at-birth standards.
These developments underscore a profound reversal in federal priorities—from earlier efforts to accommodate transgender athletes to a strong emphasis on protecting competitive fairness and biological integrity in women’s sports.

Youth and College Sports: The Real-World Impact

The impact of these shifts is most directly felt in school, club, and collegiate athletics.
  • In Virginia, transgender runner Eliza Munshi was removed from the girls’ track team and reassigned to the boys’ division.
  • In California, middle-school track athlete AB Hernandez became a national symbol of the debate after dominating girls’ events, prompting backlash and proposed rule changes in local districts.
While inclusion advocates continue to emphasize the mental health benefits of participation for transgender youth, critics argue that the rights of biological female athletes to fair competition and recognition have often been neglected—a concern now increasingly reflected in federal enforcement.

Scientific Perspectives: Competing Claims and Emerging Consensus

The medical and scientific community remains divided, but several facts are widely acknowledged.
Arguments Supporting Inclusion:
Arguments Supporting Restrictions for Biological Fairness:
Many medical professionals, particularly in sports medicine and endocrinology, emphasize that male puberty confers advantages that are not fully reversed, including:
  • Larger hearts and lungs for greater oxygen delivery and endurance.
  • Higher red blood cell counts supporting aerobic performance.
  • Longer limbs and narrower hips improving stride efficiency and agility.
  • Increased skeletal muscle mass and bone density contributing to strength and injury resistance.
These traits are not fully mitigated by hormone therapy, especially if transition begins after puberty.

D&O / EPLI Insurance Implications

For school districts, colleges, and sports organizations, the risk of litigation related to transgender participation policies intersects directly with Directors & Officers (D&O) and Employment Practices Liability Insurance (EPLI) coverage.
Will My Policy Defend the Organization?
  • Most policies include a duty to defend discrimination claims, including those under Title IX or constitutional law.
  • Defense is typically provided unless a court finds the insured knowingly and intentionally violated the law.
Will the Policy Cover Damages or Settlements?
  • Insurers may deny indemnity if there is a final judgment of intentional discrimination.
  • Disparate impact claims—where harm was unintentional—are more likely to be covered than claims of disparate treatment (intentional exclusion).
Common Policy Exclusions to Watch:
  • Knowing Violation Exclusion: May void coverage if a court finds the organization knowingly broke the law.
  • Fraud or Criminal Acts Exclusion: Denies coverage for proven unlawful conduct.
  • Prior Acts Exclusion: Prevents claims tied to events that occurred before the policy’s effective date.
Organizations must review their policy language carefully, particularly in light of increasing federal enforcement and civil rights litigation risks.

Conclusion: Navigating Law, Fairness, and Risk in 2025 and Beyond

The national debate over transgender participation in sports has rapidly shifted from accommodation to enforcement, with biological female protections now driving federal and institutional policy. The government is no longer only regulating participation—it is actively reversing athletic outcomes, restoring titles to biological women, and tying compliance to federal funding.
  • Supporters of inclusion continue to focus on dignity, identity, and mental health.
  • Advocates for restriction emphasize fairness, safety, and the original intent of Title IX.
  • Insurers and administrators must evaluate rapidly evolving legal standards and policy risks.
With Supreme Court rulings expected in 2026 and new compliance mandates already in effect, every organization involved in sports—from youth leagues to universities—should:
  • Review internal participation and eligibility policies,
  • Seek legal and medical guidance on compliance,
  • Seek advice from your governing body
  • And ensure their insurance coverage aligns with their current practices and federal obligations.

Youth Sports Misconduct Extends To Social Media

The Digital Extension of Unsportsmanlike Conduct

As the new school year kicks off, excitement builds around youth sports and extracurricular activities. But alongside the spirit of teamwork and competition, coaches and administrators must also be alert to rising concerns—particularly bullying and cyberbullying.

What many may not realize is that sportsmanship now extends beyond the playing field. In today’s digital age, misconduct can occur through smartphones and social media platforms, exposing athletes, coaches, and organizations to serious risks.


Cyberbullying: A Modern Form of Sports Misconduct

Traditionally, sportsmanship focused on in-game behavior—respect for teammates, opponents, and officials. Today, misconduct can happen online, and it’s just as damaging.

Cyberbullying in youth sports includes the use of digital communication to:

  • Harass
  • Frighten
  • Intimidate
  • Humiliate
  • Threaten
  • Exclude or socially isolate

It also includes actions intended to diminish another participant physically, emotionally, or sexually. These behaviors violate Safe Sport risk management policies, especially when a staff member is aware (or should be aware) and fails to intervene.


Where Cyberbullying Typically Happens

According to StopBullying.gov, common platforms where cyberbullying takes place include:

  • Social media apps like Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, TikTok, and X 

  • Text messaging and mobile apps

  • Online chat and direct messaging services

  • Forums and message boards such as Reddit

  • Email

  • Online multiplayer gaming platforms


Legal Considerations: What You Need to Know

Although no federal law directly targets cyberbullying, state laws vary in how they address the issue.
➡️ Check here to see your state’s cyberbullying laws.

It’s also important to understand that cyberbullying isn’t limited to athletes. Parents, guardians, or other individuals may also be responsible for harmful online behavior.

Organizations must draw a clear line: while building team unity and encouraging performance is acceptable, any action that crosses into bullying or abuse must be addressed immediately.


Consequences for Cyberbullying

Anyone—whether a participant or guardian—found engaging in bullying behavior should face appropriate disciplinary measures, which may include:

  • Suspension
  • Permanent ban from the organization
  • Referral to law enforcement

Lawsuits Related to Cyberbullying in Youth Sports

With digital communication so widespread, a single inappropriate message or post can trigger serious legal and reputational damage. Common allegations tied to online misconduct may include:

  • Negligence
  • Abuse or harassment
  • Emotional distress
  • Personal injury
  • Violation of organizational policies or bylaws

Organizations that ignore cyberbullying complaints risk lawsuits and liability claims—especially if proper prevention and response protocols aren’t in place.


How to Protect Your Organization

To minimize risk and ensure safety, every youth sports organization should take the following steps:

  1. Implement a comprehensive Child Abuse Protection Plan

  2. Provide staff training to recognize, report, and prevent bullying and cyberbullying.

  3. Secure appropriate insurance coverage, including:

To learn more, contact Sadler Sports & Recreation Insurance at (800) 622-7370 or click “Get Quote” in the top navigation bar on our website.


Protect Yourself

In youth sports, sportsmanship doesn’t stop at the whistle. It extends into every interaction—both on and off the field, and now, online. By staying informed and proactive, leaders can foster a positive environment while reducing the risk of misconduct and liability.

SADLER CLIENT CELEBRATES NATIONAL CHAMPIONSHIP

UofSC Club Sports men’s lacrosse team climbs to the top after overcoming funding obstacles

In May, a second-straight national championship win was within the grasp of the University of South Carolina men’s lacrosse club team. But to compete for the title, they had to cough up $20,000 in travel costs. The trip to Round Rock, Texas was not something the Gamecocks were prepared to finance. Worse, they had only a three-day window to purchase the airline tickets. 

The lacrosse team’s scramble to fund their trip to the MCLA finals underscored the contrast between how club sports operate versus NCAA athletics at the university. Most of UofSC’s club sport programs are run by students. So much goes into it, according to club president William Lohoff-Gaida, that it can feel like a job.

Creating a budget with limited funding is one of student-athletes’ many tasks. Whether a club team has a shot at postseason play is unpredictable, and any related logistics are unknown as they plan for yearly spending. The club might hope for a shot at the championship, but they can’t budget for it.

Various resources have to be accounted for in their planning, with regular-season costs for each team member in the 2022 season of between $2,000 and $3,000. This left no money for funding the postseason trip, which would cost $420 per airline ticket for 45 players and four coaches, not to mention lodging and additional transportation. The club asked for another $750 in dues from each player and joined forces with Columbia’s Village Idiot Pizza restaurant, who helped with some of the travel and lodging costs.   

An online fundraiser yielded the greatest proceeds toward the Gamecocks’ travel expenses. The team’s treasurer said they would not have been able to buy the tickets without the fundraiser, according to Lohoff-Gaida. 

Peter Candela, the club’s head coach and manager of many club logistics, says that the club team stands out from other student athletes at the university. While other athletes only have daily worries like other sports, the club team has to worry about administrative tasks like scheduling and finances. 

Funding a student-led organization

Credit for the success of the men’s lacrosse team goes to the athletes, according to UofSC sport programs director Justin Furlough. While Furlough’s department helps the team acquire necessary resources such as insurance and medical care, the students are responsible for everything else. They plan a budget, which has to be approved by a sport club executive board. The board then issues the team a piece of the $35,977 reserved for distribution among the school’s 56 club programs. 

With so little funding, the budget quickly runs out of room for potential postseason play. The student-run executive board was able to secure nearly double the club sports’ 2022 budget for the 2023 fiscal year, on a trial basis. The increase in funds sounds promising for next season, but funding from the school over the past year amounted to only 1% of the team’s overall costs. As reported by Lohoff-Gaida, this year’s full season cost around $200,000. Funding from the school was only $2,000.

Regular-season travel eats up the majority of the lacrosse team’s budget. The team schedules games in Florida, Virginia and Arizona throughout the season. They have to play high-ranked teams, Lohoff-Gaida said, so they can maintain a high ranking.  

In order to bridge what seems to be an impossibly large gap between school funding and costs, the student-athletes have to find innovative ways to raise money. They run an online store that sells team merchandise. They also collaborated with Village Idiot Pizza, who hosted a fundraiser and donated a percentage of the evening’s regular profits to the team. Village Idiot then held a watch party for the national championship game, which was a success, according to Lohoff-Gaida.

The men’s lacrosse club is also driven by other supporters like Shelly Smith, the South Carolina women’s soccer coach. According to Candela, Smith is a huge fan of the team, as is her husband Jamie Smith, the associate women’s soccer coach. The Smiths bought the team dinner when they were in Texas for the championship.

The construction of a championship team

Two consecutive MCLA titles have made the UofSC men’s lacrosse team an appealing option for players who don’t want the sport to dominate their lives. Players trying out for the lacrosse team must maintain at least a 2.5 GPA and have to be enrolled in classes full-time. Of approximately 150 students who vied for a spot on the club lacrosse team this year, 45 made the roster. Then those students’ schedules required synchronization to find practice times. Lohoff-Gaida said that while the club meets for practice twice a week, it’s playing games that really builds their strength as a team.

The players hail from 10 different states, including Maryland and New York, both known for their lacrosse culture, according to Lohoff-Gaida. Only 14 of the 45 team members are South Carolina natives. Some of the members transferred to the club from Division I, which Lohoff-Gaida said is much more demanding, with less time for schoolwork or a social life. A lot of the team members transferred from those big programs to avoid the full-time lacrosse obligation, according to Candela. The schedule of practicing two days a week allows them to enjoy the college experience while also participating in a competitive sport. 

UofSC Club Sports men's lacrosseA rocky start to the club sport season

The Gamecocks have battled through unfavorable situations to reach the national title. The season got off to a shaky start, with a 3-3 record early in the season. They managed to turn things around by winning 14 games in a row, 10 of those before nationals. Due to poor field conditions, they first played Georgia Tech at Columbia’s Heathwood Hall Episcopal School in March. The relocated game ended in a muddy loss, but the team kicked off their winning streak during the very next game, defeating Cal Poly 14-8. 

The Gamecocks also won a game at Clemson’s soccer stadium, the Historic Riggs Field. This was a triumph for Lohoff-Gaida, who one day wants to see the club play at Stone Stadium, USC’s own soccer venue. They also won a crucial game in the Southeastern Lacrosse Conference Division I Tournament. 

Life after a club sports victory

Once the lacrosse club made it to Texas, they played and won against Arizona, Liberty, and Brigham Young University. Then they played Georgia Tech for the third time: after the loss in March and a win in April. 

When the Gamecocks met the Yellow Jackets for the final time at the championship game, they were battling heat so brutal some of their cleats melted. That time the weather didn’t keep them from the win. Social media posts by Dawn Staley and Shane Beamer, UofSC’s women’s basketball coach and football coaches, cheered them on. UofSC alum Darius Rucker also posted a congratulatory tweet. Lohoff-Gaida and Candela expressed their gratitude and hope for similar and continued support .

Given the lacrosse players who already flock to UofSC, Lohoff-Gaida thinks that if the university started an NCAA lacrosse program, it would be a success, possibly even going on to Division I. According to Furlough, a UofSC club has never made the transition to NCAA sport. He and Candela are not sure it would be such a positive change. For one thing, current lacrosse club players would not be guaranteed a spot in an NCAA program.  That’s because admission is talent- and even recruitment-based rather than on the payment of dues and meeting eligibility in club sports. For another, the team is united by all the work they put in to keep the club running. 

Funding for an NCAA team would be the biggest obstacle, Candela said. He believes UofSC securing the funds and building the first NCAA men’s lacrosse team in the SEC would result in a recruiting advantage. Although Candela attributes the men’s lacrosse team’s success to the club culture, he says one day an NCAA program could be a good thing for the state of South Carolina.  

Insurance for college and university club sports 

Sadler Sports and Recreation Insurance proudly provides the General Liability and Accident insurance for UofSC Club Sports and is aggressively seeking new business. Finding sports insurance for club sports programs can be difficult. This is because many clubs participate in high-risk activities such as tackle football, rugby, soccer and include activity clubs like SCUBA. Visit our webpage for college and university club and intramural sports insurance for more information or a quote. We also provide assistance in developing risk management programs for club and intramural sports.


Source: Augusta Stone. “Money, mud fests and melted cleats: Inside USC men’s lacrosse club’s championship win.” The State Newspaper, June 10, 2022. 

Photos courtesy of UofSC Office of Campus Recreation

$300M Locker Room Peeping Lawsuit Alleges Child Abuse / Privacy Issues

Lessons to be learned about managing locker rooms to prevent child abuse and invasion of privacy

The class-action lawsuit filed in S.C. State Court alleges that Bishop England High School in Charleston, South Carolina knowingly allowed windows for staff viewing of students inside the boy’s and girls’ gym locker rooms. The windows were apparently installed in 1998 when Bishop England opened their new campus. After 21 years, an undisclosed number of former and some current students spoke out against the school, which is under the oversight of the Diocese Of Charleston. The list of defendants includes not only Bishop England and the Diocese of Charleston but also Bishop Robert Guglielmone. Bishop Guglielmone recently retired in May of 2019 at the age of 75.

This case is illustrative for the youth sports clients of Sadler Sports Insurance that have locker rooms and changing rooms either on owned or leased premises or at other premises. Note that the definition of child abuse includes non-touching offenses such as voyeurism and the photographing of minors for sexual purposes when they have an expectation of privacy. There can be a fine line between the duty to monitor and prevent bullying and hazing versus sexual misconduct. The U.S. Center for SafeSport has published guidelines for locker rooms and changing areas which maximizes privacy and child abuse protection for athletes by not allowing a continuous presence by staff inside of locker rooms. Instead, staff should be located directly outside of locker rooms and should be on call if a problem arises but periodic sweeps are encouraged.

Public knowledge emerges from voyeurism charge against school employee with window overlooking locker rooms

Public knowledge first emerged in 2019 when the school’s sports information director, Jeffrey Alan Scofield, was arrested for voyeurism. The employee told detectives that his office window overlooked the boys’ locker room, and he set up his phone between the windows and blinds for video recording. He then downloaded the videos onto a school computer. The employee was subsequently fired, convicted of voyeurism, and sentenced to time served plus 18 months probation along with being listed under the state’s sexual offender registry with a requirement to seek mental health counseling.

Defendants sued for $300 million for invasion of privacy and sexually abusive actions

The lawsuit alleges that Bishop England engaged in “dishonest, deceptive and sexually abusive actions” when it failed to protect students. The charges include invasion of privacy, various acts of negligence, breach of warranty, and unjust enrichment. The Diocese publicly denounced the accusation as having absolutely no merit stating thehigh school sued for $300 million for viewing windows in locker room windows were in place merely to supervise students to prevent smoking, bullying, fighting, and other improper behavior. The plaintiffs are asking for $300 million in damages. Larry Richter, a previous graduate of the high school in the 1960s, is the attorney handling the case on behalf of the plaintiffs. Richter enacted a previous class-action case against the Diocese of Charleston. He won a $12 million settlement on the grounds of child sexual abuse.

Since 1998, students undressed in front of coaches who had access to the windows. Richter claims the school did nothing for years to get rid of the windows. He further questions why they were ever installed in the first place.

Since the filing of the lawsuit, Bishop England has subsequently boarded over the windows and replaced them with a brick wall.

Trainings and procedures to protect students from child sexual abuse

Bishop England firmly states that they have all the proper procedures and screenings in place for new employees. The school requires all new staff to:

  • Pass a background check
  • Attend child abuse prevention training
  • Attend student boundary training
  • Sign a code of conduct overseeing how they interact with minors

Huge number of potential sex abuse victims from locker room setting

But despite these requirements and trainings, child abuse allegedly still occurred. With 687 students in the student-body, Bishop Englandsexually abusive locker room windows, high school sued High School is the largest Catholic high school in the state. Over the course of 21 years, the number of students victim to peering is theoretically in the thousands. The number gets even larger. Richter states that visiting athletes from other schools shared the locker rooms as well.

How this case applies to youth sports organizations that use locker rooms and changing areas

While this lawsuit’s subject matter occurred in the school setting, youth sports participants are subject to the same types of invasion of privacy and sexual abuse. Child abuse is not limited to just inappropriate touching. The definition of illegal child abuse is quite broad and includes voyeurism and inappropriately videotaping youth in various states of undress.

In the past, youth sports administrators keyed in solely on criminal background checks to protect their youth from predators. The problem with putting all the eggs in the background check basket is that the vast majority of predators don’t have a detectable criminal background. 

Therefore, merely running background checks is not enough to protect youth. The Safe Sport Act requires sports organizations at a minimum to provide:

  • Mandatory educational training of adult staff and volunteers with access to youth. This should include defining the various forms of child abuse including no touching offenses such as voyeurism and how to handle locker room and changing room settings.
  • Offer minor training at the discretion of the parent/guardian
  • Implement policies and procedures to reduce the chances of an incident
  • Report suspicions to local law enforcement within 24 hours
  • Prohibit retaliation for whistleblowers

Sadler Sports Insurance offers free child abuse risk management content

Be sure to check out our free child abuse/molestation risk management content which includes the industry-leading blog on the Safe Sport Act, child abuse risk management templates, types of criminal background checks, and sources of criminal background checks. The document entitled Sadler Safe Sport Child Abuse and Other Misconduct Risk Management Plan includes a section on how to manage locker rooms and changing areas.


Sources:

Caitlin Byrd. SC’s largest Catholic high school sued for $300M for invasive locker room windows. The State. February 4, 2021.

Drew Tripp. Bishop England, Diocese of Charleston sued for $300M over student exploitation claims. ABC News 4. February 4, 2021.

Catherine Kohn and Kenna Coe. $300 million lawsuit filed against Bishop England High School. Moultrie News. February 4, 2021.

 

School and Booster Club Blame Game Over Athlete Death

Lack of risk management leads to costly legal battle

The family of Joshua Mileto is seeking $15 million in damages following his fatal accident on the campus of Sachem East High School in Long Island. The suit names and alleges equal blame to both the school district and school’s booster club.

Mileto, 16, died when a log fell on his head during a summer camp exercise. He and four other players were carrying the 400-lb. log during an off-season football camp drill. The attorney for the Miletos said the suit names both parties because of the vague relationship between the two. The Sachem East Touchdown Club is registered as a nonprofit.

It remains to be seen whether coaches at the camp will also be named in the suit. Apparently, it isn’t clear yet for whom the coaches were working, the school or the booster club. Both entities played a role in running the preseason camp. The Miletos’ attorney stated the drill was too dangerous for boys that age and size.

If the school can prove it didn’t employ the coaches for the purposes of the camp, it may not have any liability, according to Michael Duffy, an attorney not involved in the case.  Michael Kaplen, a law professor a George Washington University, isn’t aware of any cases where a school district tried to shift blame onto a booster club. It would be difficult to do so, he said, because the camp took place on school property. That’s tantamount to a school district endorsement of the camp.

How schools can protect themselves

The New York State Education Department points to section 414 of education law, advising schools to not treat booster clubs as an extension of the district. The law states that the school should establish policies for use of the property that “provide for the safety and security of the pupils.”

At Sadler Insurance, we advise all facility owners, including school districts, to have an agreement clarifying the roles of the facility owner and facility user. This should include insurance requirements and an indemnification/hold harmless provision in favor of the facility owner. For more information, see Insurance for Facility Users of Recreation Departments and Schools.


Source: Jim Baumbach, Michael O’Keeffe. “Sachem East football player lawsuit would look to establish blame,” newsday.com. 09 Sept. 2017.

Benching of Youth Participants and Resulting Lawsuits

Parents who pay want their child to play

It’s not yet what you’d call a trend, but there’s certainly an uptick in the number of parents filing lawsuits to get their child off the bench and onto the playing field.

Parents put out big bucks in registrations fees, equipment and travel costs associated with high school and youth club and travel teams, to say nothing of the time they invest attending practices and traveling to games. Many parents sacrifice their time and money for their children hoping to get the attention of college coaches, earn scholarships, and improve chances of college admissions – or even advance a professional athletic career. So, it’s understandable that some are dissatisfied when their child rides the bench more than he or she plays. In other words, they expect a payoff for their investment.

There is also an increase in lawsuits by parents of children who have been cut from teams, injured, disciplined by coaches or penalized by officials. But is hiring an attorney the answer? Many are questioning not only the attitude of entitlement, but how the children, who generally play for the fun and camaraderie, are affected by such lawsuits. What are the children learning when parents step in so heavily handed to smooth the way? Will they learn they’re entitled to play on a team simply because they attend practice? And are parents setting these athletes up to be bullied by other team members?

The increasingly competitive nature of youth sports has helped shift many parents’ focus from fun, exercise and sportsmanship to an investment in their children’s academic and professional futures. Youth sports officials are watching the case of a 16-year-old volleyball player. The girl earned spot on a volleyball league but ended up on the bench, so her parents filed suit against the volleyball association, alleging it won’t let the girl play or to switch teams, per the contract she signed.

General Liability policies, which typically only respond to certain lawsuits alleging bodily injury or property damage, don’t cover these types of lawsuits that allege loss of college scholarship or loss of pro career. Such lawsuits generally require a Professional Liability endorsement on a General Liability policy or a stand alone Professional Liability policy.


Source: Tracey Schelmetic, sportsdestinations.com, 21 Apr. 2015.

AEDs and Liability in Public Schools

Will sympathy impact legislation?   

Too many communities have grieved debilitating injuries or premature deaths of high school athletes due to cardiac events. Many schools maintain automatic external defibrillators (AEDs) in an effort to prevent such tragedies.

 There are no federal mandates regarding AEDs in public schools. Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Iowa , Maryland, Michigan, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, Ohio, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Virginia and Wisconsin have passed legislation requiring some schools to maintain portable defibrillators.  California and Tennessee encourages placement in public schools.

But a debate has started over whether public schools can be held liable if the AEDs are not used. This stems from a lawsuit that will go before the Florida Supreme Court sometime this year.

What set the ball in motion

When an East County High School soccer player collapsed on the field, school personnel called 911 and performed CPR while waiting for emergency responders. The AED on campus was not utilized. Although paramedics were able to revive the student with a defibrillator and medication, he suffered severe brain damage and is in a vegetative state.

 The lawsuit argues that that the school district is liable. Lower courts found in favor of the school district, acknowledging that the school is legally obligated to try to help any student who becomes injured or ill on school grounds but not to authorize or direct specific treatment such as the use of an AED.

Florida ruling could have huge impact

If the Florida Supreme Court overturns the lower court ruling, there is potential for every youth sports facility or program to be affected. This includes both public and private facilities and programs, such as those run by school districts, local and state governments, parks and universities.

If this occurs, the next question will be whether AED training will be required of paid and volunteer coaches, referees, and organizers or risk being sued in the event of an episode such as the one in the current suit. And will these organizations be required to purchase other medical devices and provide training to avoid liability? And, of course, this could affect the cost of Liability Insurance, as typically is the case when claims are made.


Source: Mark Miller and Deborah J. LaFetra, “Fla. Lawsuit Set to Define Schools’ Legal Duty to Use AEDs,” Tampa Tribune.  16 Apri 2014

School Facility Use Liabilities

Sadler partners with schools and districts to assist in lowering liability risks

There are critical aspects of risk management for organizations that permit the use of their facility to outside groups. The video below offers detailed information on the following:

  • Why facility user groups expose schools to a huge liability potential.
  • Why users such as camps, teams, leagues, special event operators, and tournaments must carry their own insurance.
  • Why not just any insurance will adequately protect schools.
  • How to set reasonable minimum insurance standards to shield the school’s own liability insurance from paying unnecessary claims
  • Provides a specific webpage that is a reputable source of high limit, high coverage sports insurance to which facility users can be referred to INSTANTLY bind coverage and issue certificates of insurance naming school as Additional Insured.
  • How we can set up your school/school district on our automatic certificate of insurance issuance system to meet your special wording requirements every time. Nothing is more frustrating than having to tell a facility user that their insurance does not meet your requirements.
  • All of the above speeds the process and reduces hassle and frustration for all parties involved.

Insurance Requirements for Rec Facility Users

Reduce liability exposure with proper collection of certificates of insurance

Facility user groups such as teams, leagues, tournament hosts, camps, instructors, and special event operators must carry adequate insurance. In addition to providing the proper coverage, Sadler Sports Insurance can assist you in reducing your liability by:

    • setting minimum insurance limits and coverage standards that adequately protect the recreation department
    • providing a simple free checklist tool to assist in verifying insurance compliance
    • referring uninsured facility users to a specific web page where they can get an instant quote,  instantly pay, and bind coverage  without any delays or hassles. Their delays and hassles become your delays and hassles.
    • setting your recreation department up in our system so that the certificates of insurance meet your special wording requirements every time, which cuts down on your frustration over certificates that don’t meet your requirements.

The video below walks you through the process in more detail.