Archive for the ‘Lacrosse’ Category

Youth Concussions: Advice From American Academy of Pediatrics

The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) has released an updated clinical report titled “Sport-Related Concussion in Children and Adolescents” (2023), offering critical new insights on diagnosis, treatment, and prevention of concussions in youth sports. This update builds on the original 2010 guidance, reflecting over a decade of research and evolving clinical practices.
Below is a breakdown of the most significant and evidence-based takeaways from the AAP report and related current literature, with an emphasis on actionable guidance for parents, coaches, and healthcare providers.

Understanding Concussions: Beyond a Simple “Bump on the Head”

Concussions are complex neurometabolic injuries caused by biomechanical forces such as a direct hit or whiplash-like motion. These forces disrupt normal brain cell function, triggering a cascade of metabolic changes—like potassium ion shifts, glutamate release, and reduced cerebral blood flow—that impair brain performance.

Rest & Recovery: What the Science Supports

After a concussion, brief rest (24–48 hours) is beneficial, but extended physical and cognitive inactivity can delay recovery. The AAP recommends a stepwise return-to-learn and return-to-play protocol under professional supervision.

Concussion Reporting Has Increased – But Why?

Reported youth concussion rates have risen over the past decade, with studies indicating increases between 57% and 200%. However, this rise likely reflects better recognition and reporting, not a true increase in incidence.
  • Initiatives like the CDC HEADS UP program have helped raise awareness and improve concussion protocols across school and recreational sports.

Gender Differences in Concussion Risk

Multiple studies show that female athletes are more likely than males to report concussion symptoms and tend to have higher concussion rates in sports such as soccer and basketball.
Potential reasons include:
  • Lower neck strength in female athletes, may lead to greater head acceleration upon impact.
  • Hormonal factors like estrogen may influence brain response to injury, though research is ongoing.
In contrast, boys have higher concussion rates in contact-heavy sports like football, lacrosse, and ice hockey.

Youth Tackle Football: Higher Risk in Older Children

Data suggest that players aged 11–12 experience significantly more concussions than those aged 8–10 in youth football programs. One study found an almost 2.5x increased risk for the older age group.

Common Concussion Symptoms in Youth

The AAP identifies the following as the most frequently reported symptoms among children and teens with concussions:
  • Headache: 86–96%
  • Dizziness: 65–75%
  • Difficulty concentrating: 48–61%
  • Confusion: 40–46%
These symptoms can also mimic pre-existing conditions such as migraine, ADHD, or sleep disorders, making proper clinical evaluation crucial.

SCAT Tools for Sideline Evaluation

The Sport Concussion Assessment Tool (SCAT5) and Child SCAT5 are the most widely used tools for sideline concussion screening. They include:
  • Symptom checklists
  • Memory and concentration tasks
  • Balance tests
  • Neurological assessments
However, SCAT tools are not diagnostic and are most useful when compared to baseline assessments. Also, children under 12 may perform poorly on certain cognitive tasks, so the Child SCAT5 should be used for this group.
Visual-based tools like the King-Devick test are promising but not yet validated for widespread clinical use in children.

Are CT or MRI Scans Needed After a Concussion?

Imaging tests like CT scans or MRIs are not recommended for diagnosing concussions unless a more serious brain injury is suspected (e.g., skull fracture, hemorrhage).
  • CT scans are faster but expose children to radiation.
  • MRI is better for detecting subtle injuries like white matter damage, but is more expensive and less accessible in emergencies.
Imaging should only be used when symptoms suggest a structural brain injury.

Baseline Neurocognitive Testing: Not Foolproof

Computer-based tests like ImPACT or CNS Vital Signs aim to detect subtle cognitive changes post-injury, but concerns remain:
  • Results can vary from year to year, even without injury.
  • Fatigue, ADHD medication, anxiety, or poor sleep can distort results.
  • Athletes may intentionally “sandbag” baseline tests, although trained professionals can often detect this.
Baseline testing should never be the sole determinant of return-to-play decisions.

Multiple Concussions: When Should an Athlete Retire?

There is no established number of concussions that requires retirement. Instead, decisions should be individualized and made in consultation with a specialist in pediatric concussion management, particularly for athletes with:
  • Multiple concussions
  • Prolonged recovery
  • Increasing severity of symptoms

What Actually Works to Prevent Concussions?

Unproven or Ineffective Methods

  • Mouthguards: Do not reduce concussion risk, though they protect teeth and jaws.
  • High-tech helmets and brands: No significant difference between helmet models in preventing concussions.
  • Aftermarket helmet accessories (sensors, pads): No current evidence supports their effectiveness.
  • Soccer headgear: Studies show no reduction in concussion risk and may encourage more aggressive heading behavior.

Evidence-Backed Strategies

  • Education: Teaching symptom recognition and proper response protocols improves outcomes.
  • Neck Strengthening: Stronger neck muscles can help reduce head acceleration during impacts. One study showed that each pound of neck strength may reduce concussion risk by 5%.
  • Rule Changes: Policy changes like banning heading in youth soccer and limiting full-contact practices in football have reduced concussion rates.

Supplements and Biomarkers: Not Ready for Clinical Use

Though researchers are exploring biomarkers (like blood-based proteins) and nutritional supplements (such as omega-3 fatty acids) for concussion diagnosis and recovery, no supplements or biomarkers are currently validated for clinical use in youth populations.

Final Takeaways

  • Concussions in youth sports are neurological injuries, not minor knocks.
  • Rest is important, but prolonged restriction may be harmful.
  • Prevention is best achieved through education, neck strengthening, and rule enforcement—not gear or supplements.
  • Diagnosis and return-to-play decisions must

Lacrosse Safety Essentials for Teams, Clubs, Camps & Tournaments

A Sport on the Rise—Balancing Growth with Safety

Lacrosse continues to grow at both the youth and adult levels, with leagues, tournaments, and camps now thriving year-round. The sport’s fast pace and physicality bring excitement—and exposure to serious risks.
It’s critical to implement proactive risk management strategies to protect players, coaches, volunteers, and your organization.

Key Risks in Lacrosse (and How to Manage Them)

1. Concussions: A Fast Game with High Impact

The Risk: Lacrosse has one of the highest concussion rates among amateur sports. While helmets are required for boys and men, concussions still occur from stick checks, body collisions, or unexpected ground impacts. Female players, who typically don’t wear helmets, are particularly vulnerable due to differences in rules and contact expectations.
Mitigation Strategies:
  • Enforce proper technique for checks and contact.
  • Require coaches to complete concussion awareness training.
  • Follow return-to-play protocols and baseline testing for all athletes.
  • Educate players and parents on recognizing concussion symptoms.

2. Heat Illness: A Hidden Risk in Warmer Months

The Risk: Tournaments and practices in the spring and summer can expose athletes to heat-related illnesses like heat exhaustion or heatstroke, especially when wearing full gear.
Mitigation Strategies:
  • Schedule frequent water breaks and provide shaded rest areas.
  • Implement a Wet Bulb Globe Temperature policy for practice/game cancellations.
  • Educate players and coaches on early signs of dehydration and overheating.
  • Have a cold water immersion tub readily available.
  • Use cooling towels and misting fans during high-heat events.

3. Lightning Strikes: A Sudden and Deadly Threat

The Risk: Outdoor events are vulnerable to fast-moving storms. Lacrosse sticks and metal bleachers increase the danger when lightning is nearby.
Mitigation Strategies:
  • Create and enforce a lightning safety protocol.
  • Monitor real-time weather with apps and devices.
  • Immediately suspend play at the first sign of thunder or lightning—follow the 30/30 rule (30 seconds between lightning and thunder = suspend play; wait 30 minutes after last thunder to resume).
  • Identify safe shelters in advance (vehicles or buildings, not tents).

4. Child Sexual Abuse: A Silent Crisis That Demands Action

The Risk: Youth sports are a top setting for potential abuse, due to close coach-player contact and travel situations. The Federal Safe Sports Act was enacted in 2017 to address this risk.
Mitigation Strategies:
  • Require third-party criminal background checks for all adults in contact with minors.
  • Implement the “Rule of Two”—never allow one-on-one adult-minor interaction.
  • Adopt a written abuse prevention policy and provide training to comply with the Safe Sport Act.
  • Having policies to prevent “grooming” is the key to preventing sex abuse.

5. Injuries from Contact, Overuse, and Equipment

The Risk: From ankle sprains to shoulder injuries and broken fingers, lacrosse is tough on the body. Improper technique or worn-out gear can worsen the odds.
Mitigation Strategies:
  • Conduct pre-season equipment checks (helmets, goggles, pads).
  • Provide regular conditioning and mobility work to prevent overuse.
  • Maintain safe playing surfaces and perform regular field inspections.
  • Require certified officials for all sanctioned games.

6. Legal Liability: The Cost of Being Unprepared

The Risk: A single lawsuit can jeopardize your club’s future. Whether it’s an injury, abuse allegation, or volunteer misconduct, lack of proper coverage could leave board members and coaches personally liable.
Mitigation Strategies:
  • Carry General Liability and Participant Accident Insurance.
  • Use waivers for minors and adults that clearly outline participation risks.
  • Have a written risk management plan to cover all the major areas of risk and response.  a
  • Train all staff and volunteers on your risk management plan and document their agreement to comply with electronic signatures.

Why Insurance Matters for Lacrosse Programs

The stakes in lacrosse are high—and not just on the scoreboard. A player concussion, heat stroke incident, or abuse allegation can lead to serious financial fallout for even well-intentioned programs. Want real-world examples of the types of claims sports programs face? Check out our blog, Based On Actual Horror Story Claims That Our Sports Clients Have Suffered. Sadler Sports Insurance provides coverage designed specifically for the needs of amateur lacrosse operations. With over 65 years of protecting sports organizations, we understand the exposures that many programs overlook—until it’s too late.
Our coverage includes:
  • General Liability Insurance for lawsuits related to bodily injury, property damage, personal injury, and advertising injury. Coverage options can be added for Sexual Abuse and Non-Owned and Hired Auto Liability.
  • Participant Accident Insurance to help cover medical bills for injured participants. Coverage is excess of any existing family health insurance.
  • Free Risk Management Tools like safety checklists, abuse prevention policies, and training guides. See our free Risk Management Content for the best in industry protection.

Don’t Wait Until an Incident—Protect Your Program Now Through Sadler Sports

Whether you’re running a team, league, camp, or tournament, having the right protection gives your organization—and the families you serve—peace of mind. Click on Get Quote now to access our best-in-industry insurance programs, where you can:
  • Single source for Accident, General Liability, D&O Liability, Crime, and Equipment
  • Instant online quote/pay/print of proof of coverage docs and certificates for field owners.
  • High limit protection with custom coverage enhancements.
  • Current clients can access our all-in-one doc on league risk management, which serves as both educational awareness training and your written policies and procedures.

Managing Risks, Supporting Players

Lacrosse is one of the fastest-growing sports in North America—but with growth comes responsibility. From concussion management to lightning safety, every club must take proactive steps to protect their athletes and its organization.
Risk management isn’t just about avoiding lawsuits—it’s about fostering a safe, respectful environment where players can thrive. With the right tools, training, and insurance, you can confidently face the challenges of a year-round lacrosse season.

Sources:

Travel Ball: Pros, Cons, Injuries and Insurance

Travel ball has become a dominant force in youth sports, offering athletes opportunities to compete at high levels, gain exposure, and develop advanced skills. But alongside the rewards come important considerations—ranging from time commitments and physical strain to injury risks and insurance needs.

This guide explores the key benefits, challenges, common injuries, and insurance factors every parent and player should understand before committing to travel ball.


What Are Youth Travel Sports?

  • Soccer
  • Baseball
  • Softball 
  • Lacrosse
  • And others

These teams often travel regionally or nationally for tournaments, showcase events, and competitive matchups. The travel aspect introduces young athletes to higher levels of competition and broader experiences beyond local leagues.

Along with offering a valuable learning and social experience for young athletes, travel sports provide a higher level of competition than participants might find locally. Children involved in youth travel sports also have more frequent opportunities to compete.


Benefits of Youth Travel Sports

Participating in travel ball isn’t just about the game—it’s a developmental experience for both kids and their families. Here are some of the most notable advantages:

Social and Athletic Growth

  • Builds self-esteem and confidence through competitive play.
  • Offers advanced coaching and training not always found in local leagues.
  • Enhances team bonding and strengthens family relationships through shared travel experiences.

Exposure and Experience

  • Prepares young athletes for higher levels of play, including high school and college.
  • Encourages discipline, teamwork, and resilience.

Challenges of Travel Sports

While the rewards can be great, parents and athletes must weigh the costs and risks:

Financial Commitment

  • Expenses can include:
    • Registration fees
    • Travel (lodging, meals)
    • Equipment
    • Private coaching and camps

Increased Pressure

  • Athletes on elite teams often feel greater performance expectations, which can lead to stress or burnout.

Injury Risks

  • High competition levels may lead to:
    • Overuse injuries
    • Concussions
    • Torn ligaments or broken bones
    • Heatstroke
    • Accidents during travel

Injury Prevention in Travel Ball

Each year, more than 3.5 million youth sports injuries requiring medical attention are reported, according to the National SAFE KIDS Campaign and the American Academy of Pediatrics.

At Sadler Sports Insurance, we monitor injury trends across our insured programs. Our data shows:

  • More injuries occur during games than practices.
  • Injury rates rise with age and skill level.

To combat this, we advocate for education and prevention. The American Orthopaedic Society for Sports Medicine and National Council of Youth Sports created the STOP (Sports Trauma and Overuse Prevention) Sports Injuries program. You can explore sport-specific injury prevention tips through their official site.


A Parent’s Perspective on Travel Soccer

As a parent of two daughters who played for SC United FC, my family had a deeply positive experience with travel soccer. The organization maintained a strong focus on:

  • Player safety
  • High-quality coaching
  • Solid risk management practices, including concussion protocols, child protection, and legal waivers

These safeguards helped us focus on the joy of the game. Over the years, we built lasting friendships with teammates and fellow families. Now that my youngest is in college, I often find myself reminiscing about those travel weekends.


Why Travel Ball Insurance Matters

At Sadler Sports & Recreation Insurance, we understand the unique challenges faced by travel sports organizations. We offer comprehensive insurance programs with:

Commonly Needed Travel Team Insurance Policies:

We’re here to protect everyone involved—from directors and coaches to volunteers and athletes.

SADLER CLIENT CELEBRATES NATIONAL CHAMPIONSHIP

UofSC Club Sports men’s lacrosse team climbs to the top after overcoming funding obstacles

In May, a second-straight national championship win was within the grasp of the University of South Carolina men’s lacrosse club team. But to compete for the title, they had to cough up $20,000 in travel costs. The trip to Round Rock, Texas was not something the Gamecocks were prepared to finance. Worse, they had only a three-day window to purchase the airline tickets. 

The lacrosse team’s scramble to fund their trip to the MCLA finals underscored the contrast between how club sports operate versus NCAA athletics at the university. Most of UofSC’s club sport programs are run by students. So much goes into it, according to club president William Lohoff-Gaida, that it can feel like a job.

Creating a budget with limited funding is one of student-athletes’ many tasks. Whether a club team has a shot at postseason play is unpredictable, and any related logistics are unknown as they plan for yearly spending. The club might hope for a shot at the championship, but they can’t budget for it.

Various resources have to be accounted for in their planning, with regular-season costs for each team member in the 2022 season of between $2,000 and $3,000. This left no money for funding the postseason trip, which would cost $420 per airline ticket for 45 players and four coaches, not to mention lodging and additional transportation. The club asked for another $750 in dues from each player and joined forces with Columbia’s Village Idiot Pizza restaurant, who helped with some of the travel and lodging costs.   

An online fundraiser yielded the greatest proceeds toward the Gamecocks’ travel expenses. The team’s treasurer said they would not have been able to buy the tickets without the fundraiser, according to Lohoff-Gaida. 

Peter Candela, the club’s head coach and manager of many club logistics, says that the club team stands out from other student athletes at the university. While other athletes only have daily worries like other sports, the club team has to worry about administrative tasks like scheduling and finances. 

Funding a student-led organization

Credit for the success of the men’s lacrosse team goes to the athletes, according to UofSC sport programs director Justin Furlough. While Furlough’s department helps the team acquire necessary resources such as insurance and medical care, the students are responsible for everything else. They plan a budget, which has to be approved by a sport club executive board. The board then issues the team a piece of the $35,977 reserved for distribution among the school’s 56 club programs. 

With so little funding, the budget quickly runs out of room for potential postseason play. The student-run executive board was able to secure nearly double the club sports’ 2022 budget for the 2023 fiscal year, on a trial basis. The increase in funds sounds promising for next season, but funding from the school over the past year amounted to only 1% of the team’s overall costs. As reported by Lohoff-Gaida, this year’s full season cost around $200,000. Funding from the school was only $2,000.

Regular-season travel eats up the majority of the lacrosse team’s budget. The team schedules games in Florida, Virginia and Arizona throughout the season. They have to play high-ranked teams, Lohoff-Gaida said, so they can maintain a high ranking.  

In order to bridge what seems to be an impossibly large gap between school funding and costs, the student-athletes have to find innovative ways to raise money. They run an online store that sells team merchandise. They also collaborated with Village Idiot Pizza, who hosted a fundraiser and donated a percentage of the evening’s regular profits to the team. Village Idiot then held a watch party for the national championship game, which was a success, according to Lohoff-Gaida.

The men’s lacrosse club is also driven by other supporters like Shelly Smith, the South Carolina women’s soccer coach. According to Candela, Smith is a huge fan of the team, as is her husband Jamie Smith, the associate women’s soccer coach. The Smiths bought the team dinner when they were in Texas for the championship.

The construction of a championship team

Two consecutive MCLA titles have made the UofSC men’s lacrosse team an appealing option for players who don’t want the sport to dominate their lives. Players trying out for the lacrosse team must maintain at least a 2.5 GPA and have to be enrolled in classes full-time. Of approximately 150 students who vied for a spot on the club lacrosse team this year, 45 made the roster. Then those students’ schedules required synchronization to find practice times. Lohoff-Gaida said that while the club meets for practice twice a week, it’s playing games that really builds their strength as a team.

The players hail from 10 different states, including Maryland and New York, both known for their lacrosse culture, according to Lohoff-Gaida. Only 14 of the 45 team members are South Carolina natives. Some of the members transferred to the club from Division I, which Lohoff-Gaida said is much more demanding, with less time for schoolwork or a social life. A lot of the team members transferred from those big programs to avoid the full-time lacrosse obligation, according to Candela. The schedule of practicing two days a week allows them to enjoy the college experience while also participating in a competitive sport. 

UofSC Club Sports men's lacrosseA rocky start to the club sport season

The Gamecocks have battled through unfavorable situations to reach the national title. The season got off to a shaky start, with a 3-3 record early in the season. They managed to turn things around by winning 14 games in a row, 10 of those before nationals. Due to poor field conditions, they first played Georgia Tech at Columbia’s Heathwood Hall Episcopal School in March. The relocated game ended in a muddy loss, but the team kicked off their winning streak during the very next game, defeating Cal Poly 14-8. 

The Gamecocks also won a game at Clemson’s soccer stadium, the Historic Riggs Field. This was a triumph for Lohoff-Gaida, who one day wants to see the club play at Stone Stadium, USC’s own soccer venue. They also won a crucial game in the Southeastern Lacrosse Conference Division I Tournament. 

Life after a club sports victory

Once the lacrosse club made it to Texas, they played and won against Arizona, Liberty, and Brigham Young University. Then they played Georgia Tech for the third time: after the loss in March and a win in April. 

When the Gamecocks met the Yellow Jackets for the final time at the championship game, they were battling heat so brutal some of their cleats melted. That time the weather didn’t keep them from the win. Social media posts by Dawn Staley and Shane Beamer, UofSC’s women’s basketball coach and football coaches, cheered them on. UofSC alum Darius Rucker also posted a congratulatory tweet. Lohoff-Gaida and Candela expressed their gratitude and hope for similar and continued support .

Given the lacrosse players who already flock to UofSC, Lohoff-Gaida thinks that if the university started an NCAA lacrosse program, it would be a success, possibly even going on to Division I. According to Furlough, a UofSC club has never made the transition to NCAA sport. He and Candela are not sure it would be such a positive change. For one thing, current lacrosse club players would not be guaranteed a spot in an NCAA program.  That’s because admission is talent- and even recruitment-based rather than on the payment of dues and meeting eligibility in club sports. For another, the team is united by all the work they put in to keep the club running. 

Funding for an NCAA team would be the biggest obstacle, Candela said. He believes UofSC securing the funds and building the first NCAA men’s lacrosse team in the SEC would result in a recruiting advantage. Although Candela attributes the men’s lacrosse team’s success to the club culture, he says one day an NCAA program could be a good thing for the state of South Carolina.  

Insurance for college and university club sports 

Sadler Sports and Recreation Insurance proudly provides the General Liability and Accident insurance for UofSC Club Sports and is aggressively seeking new business. Finding sports insurance for club sports programs can be difficult. This is because many clubs participate in high-risk activities such as tackle football, rugby, soccer and include activity clubs like SCUBA. Visit our webpage for college and university club and intramural sports insurance for more information or a quote. We also provide assistance in developing risk management programs for club and intramural sports.


Source: Augusta Stone. “Money, mud fests and melted cleats: Inside USC men’s lacrosse club’s championship win.” The State Newspaper, June 10, 2022. 

Photos courtesy of UofSC Office of Campus Recreation

Commotio Cordis In Youth Sports: AED’s and Chest Protectors

Looking to Provide Athletes the Best Heart Protection Possible

Commotio cordis is a sudden cardiac arrhythmia caused by a direct blow to the chest. It typically results from a low-velocity impact to the chest from a thrown or batted ball, puck, or other object, typically traveling between 20 and 50 mph. The risk increases the closer the impact is to the center of the heart. Death results when an abnormal rhythm, ventricular fibrillation, develops. However, blood circulation to the heart may also be affected.

For commotio cordis to occur, the impact has to be precisely timed to strike the heart during a 15–30 millisecond phase of the electrical cycle. It can cause sudden death in young baseball, softball, and hockey players, as well as other athletes.


Commotio Cordis by the Numbers

  • The sport with the highest incidence of commotio cordis is baseball, followed by softball, hockey, football, soccer and lacrosse.
  • An overwhelming 95 percent of cases affect males.
  • The most frequently affected age group is 10 to 18 years.
  • Since 1995, the U.S. Commotio Cordis Registry has received reports of over 250+ cases. Many more unreported cases are suspected of having occurred.
  • Recent registry data show survival rates have improved dramatically — now approximately 40–60% — due to faster recognition, CPR, and AED use.

Survival Outcome

While instances of commotio cordis are rare, historically, survival was below 10%. However, modern data show survival has improved substantially when CPR and defibrillation occur rapidly.

Responding with CPR efforts within 3 minutes or less is critical. Studies indicate that survival odds are greatly enhanced if an automated external defibrillator (AED) shock can be delivered promptly. Early CPR and rapid AED use now represent the strongest predictors of survival.

Most ballparks still lack accessible AEDs, and those that do must have well-practiced Emergency Action Plans (EAPs) that include staff trained to retrieve and use the device immediately. The NFHS now recomAEDs and Risk Managementmends venue-specific EAPs reviewed annually, with AEDs reachable within 3 minutes of every playing area. Otherwise, all preparation is for naught.

Also, the high-profile lawsuit in New Jersey involving a pitcher struck by a batted ball from an alleged “hot bat” involved commotio cordis and permanent disability. The metal bat manufacturer and others were sued. It is interesting to note that commotio cordis usually occurs only when a projectile travels at a relatively moderate speed — usually between 20 and 50 mph — making this case unique.


Protecting Against Commotio Cordis

Researchers have been looking for solutions, typically in the form of chest protectors. But statistics show that somewhere between 20 and 30 percent of commotio cordis victims collapsed while wearing chest protection of some sort. Obviously, this means that the protection athletes were given wasn’t good enough.

Educating coaches, players, and parents about the importance of technique and situational awareness is critical. For example, baseball and softball players should be taught to step aside or turn and deflect balls using their shoulders, not their chest walls.

Commotio cordis is not related to an underlying heart condition; therefore, susceptibility cannot be predetermined by medical screening.

Spectators, players, and staff need to be able to recognize the signs of commotio cordis and take immediate action if a player is struck in the chest and collapses — call 911, begin CPR, and use an AED without delay.


New NOCSAE Standards in Protection

In July 2018, the National Operating Committee on Standards for Athletic Equipment (NOCSAE) set the world’s first performance standard for chest protection from commotio cordis (NOCSAE ND200). NOCSAE developed separate versions for baseball and lacrosse. Governing bodies of the various sports decide whether to require compliance and when to enforce it.

The ND200 standard has since been updated (most recently ND200-22, effective February 2023), reaffirming its performance levels while clarifying test procedures.


The Science Behind the New Standards

Together with the Louis J. Acompora Memorial Foundation, NOCSAE funded more than $1.1 million in research that pinpointed the cause of commotio cordis, including the critical moment of occurrence. To test impacts to the chest and heart, research engineers developed a mechanical surrogate torso that mimics the human response. All this led to NOCSAE creating the first commotio cordis-specific chest protection standard.

NOCSAE’s goal is to significantly reduce — though not eliminate — the risk of death from commotio cordis for athletes using equipment certified to this standard.


Chest Protector Certifications By SEI

The Safety Equipment Institute (SEI) issues certifications for chest protectors that meet NOCSAE’s ND200 standard. The NOCSAE criteria support a test method that produces reliable measurements to evaluate various types of chest protectors.

Manufacturers participating in SEI’s certification program must have their facilities audited annually for quality assurance. All SEI- and NOCSAE-certified products are retested and recertified each year. SEI remains the world’s premier certification body for protective sports equipment.

Consumers and coaches can verify model compliance at SEI’s public directory, by searching “ND200” and the relevant sport (baseball or lacrosse).


High School Rule Change in Baseball For Catchers

The NOCSAE standard resulted in multiple rule changes:

  • Baseball (NFHS): Rule 1-5-3, effective January 1, 2020, requires all high school catchers to wear NOCSAE ND200-compliant chest protectors.

  • Lacrosse: Goalies (boys’ and girls’) have been required to wear ND200-certified chest protectors since January 1, 2021, and boys’ field players must wear ND200-certified heart-protective shoulder pads since January 1, 2022, under USA Lacrosse, NFHS, and NCAA rules.

These changes provide assurance that athletes are using equipment tested to the latest standards for heart protection.


No Guarantees of Protection and Ongoing Debate

It’s important to note that neither NOCSAE nor SEI offers any guarantees of protection from the certified chest protectors. They clearly state that no thoracic or chest protector can prevent all cardiac injuries, and that catastrophic injury or death may still occur.

Opponents of the standard argue that manufacturers cannot claim prevention, and question whether the additional expense of compliance is justified given the rarity of the condition. Others express concern about potential side effects such as added bulk or heat stress.

However, most medical and sports-safety experts emphasize that ND200-certified gear, combined with early CPR/AED access and proper technique, offers the best currently available multilayer defense against commotio cordis.


If you found this blog on commotio cordis to be beneficial, please check out our other sports risk management content and other risk management blog posts.

Commotio cordis

Commotio Cordis: Proposed NOCSAE Standard for Chest Protectors

“If we can stop a bullet, we can stop a ball”

Baseball is arguably one of the safest team sports. But it’s also where we see the most incidents of commotio cordis, a sudden cardiac arrhythmia caused by a direct blow to the chest. While instances of commotio cordis are rare, one death is too many.

Heart attacks among teen athletes are quite rare, and are most often a result of an underlying physical defect. Commotio cordis has no correlation to the physical health of the victim. According to lab tests at Tufts University Medical Center, it occurs when an object traveling approximately 40 mph makes impact directly over the heart in the milliseconds between heartbeats.

Who’s at risk and why

Catchers, pitchers and infielders are most at risk for blows by high-speed balls. Lacrosse and hockey players are also susceptible to being struck by rocketed balls and pucks. Boys under the age of 15 are most at risk of commotio cordis because their chest walls are still flexible as their bones continue developing into their early 20s.

The best chance victims have for surviving commotio cordis is resuscitation by a defibrillator, a device not housed at every ballfield. And if one is available, there needs to be someone in attendance who has been trained in its proper use.

Equipment manufacturers relying on science to help reduce the risk

But researchers are coming up with another solution. Statistics show that nearly one third of commotio cordis victims collapsed while wearing chest protection of some sort, which means that the protection athletes were given wasn’t good enough.

In January, the National Operating Committee on Standards for Athletic Equipment (NOCSAE) proposed the first standard for chest protectors used in baseball and lacrosse with the intention of reducing the risk of cardiac events. To meet the standard, manufacturers have to come up with a material that will distribute the force of the blow but not affect movements of the players.

Earlier this year, Mark Link, a Tufts University Medical Center heart specialist, published results of tests run on a model made of foam and a combination of polymers that appears promising. The company that developed the material, Unequal Technologies, plans to test it’s chest protectors and heart-covering shirts against the NOCSAE standard. Other manufacturers are visiting the NOCSAE laboratories to educate themselves on the testing process so they can modify their products to comply with the standard.


Source: Lauran Neergaard. “Performance standard proposed for chest protector in baseball, softball.” www. santacruzsentinel.com. 30 May 2016.

Youth Athletes and Concussion Recovery

Too many parents following outdated medical advice

Starve a cold, feed a fever. Swimming within 30 minutes of eating causes cramps. Cracking your knuckles causes arthritis. Tilt the head back to stop a nosebleed. All outdated but once heavily relied upon advice from the medical community. Sadly, these and similarly unsubstantiated notions continue to circulate. And apparently so are incorrect ideas about concussion recovery.

Despite ongoing media attention and education efforts surrounding concussions, research shows that many parents still rely on outdated advice when monitoring their concussed children. Where once the impact of concussions was downplayed, apparently now parents are going to the opposite extreme and impeding recovery.

A national survey conducted by UCLA Health asked 569 parents how they would care for a child with concussion symptoms that persisted a week following the head injury. More than 75% said they would wake their child to check on them throughout the night and 84% said they would not permit the child to participate in any physical activity. About 65% said they prohibit use of electronic devices.

Making a healthy recovery

Frequent disruption or lack of sleep can affect memory, moods and energy levels, which are exactly what doctors use to measure concussion recovery. Once the child has been examined by a medical professional and determined to be at no further risk, sleep will help the brain recover more quickly, according to Christopher Giza, a UCLA paediatric neurologist.

And while contact sports are to be avoided until the child is fully recovered and cleared by a medical professional, mild exercise and aerobic activities such as walking and bike riding promote the healing process and overall good health.

As for electronic devices, it’s a good idea to keep kids off them during the early days of the injury. But easing them into their normal social, intellectual and physical activity is what’s best.

Most concussion patients make a full recovery, though dizziness and headaches can persist for weeks. Parents should always heed the advice of the physician monitoring the child and remember that rest and pain relievers for headaches are the best treatments in most cases.


Source: “Parents following outdated concussion tips,” www.sbs.com.au. 08 Sept. 2016.

Protecting Against Risk of Commotio Cordis

Study shows new chest protector is effective and youth athletes most at risk.

Athletic chest protectors are critical to the safety of hockey and lacrosse goalies, baseball/softball catchers, and umpires. There is a wide assortment of chest protectors on the market, most of which have proven to be less than adequate against serious injury and can give a false sense of security.

But one manufacturer’s product apparently now offers better protection from potentially fatal blows to the chest.

The Unequal Technologies HART Chest Protector have proven 95 percent effective in the prevention of Commotio cordis,  according to a study published in The Clinical Journal of Sports Medicine. Commotio cordis is a sudden disruption of the cardiac rhythm caused by a forceful impact to the chest that often results in fatal cardiac arrest.

Unequal Technologies develops protective padding for a variety of athletic of headgear, including the popular Halo headband.

Youth athletes under the age of 16 are most at risk from such incidents. About 10 to 20 cases occur annually in the U.S. More than one-third of Commotio cordis incidents occur in athletes wearing chest protectors, according to a study published in 2013. Therefore, it’s paramount that appropriate padding is properly placed.

For more information on Commotio cordis, click here.


Source: “Study Finds Unequal Technologies’ Chest Protectors To Be First To Significantly Reduce Risk Cardiac Concussions For Youth Athletes,” www.sporttechie.com. 22 April, 2016.

Youth Baseball and Eye Injuries

Looking at preventative measures

As everyone knows, baseball season is now in full swing. But what many probably don’t know is that youth athletes under the age of 14 incur more eye injuries in baseball and softball than any other sport. In rare instances, these injuries can result in permanent damage or even blindness.

Overall, there are more than 40,000 eye injuries reported each year, most occurring in baseball and basketball, followed by water and racquet sports. Balls, bats, pucks, racquets, and sticks are used in the sports that pose the highest risk for eye injuries. These sports also typically include body contact.

The leading cause of child blindness in the U.S. is injury, with most cases occurring in sports-related activities, according to the National Eye Institute. Penetration, blunt trauma and radiation are the most common causes of sports-related eye injuries. Exposure to the sun’s ultraviolet rays can result in radiation damage, which can be a particular risk when snow skiing, water skiing and participating in other water and snow sports.

Prevention measures

According to Jay Novetsky, 90% of sports-related eye injuries are preventable. Novetsky, an eye surgeon at the Vision Institute of Michigan, advocates for protective eyewear as part of every sports’ regulated safety equipment, such as safety shields, safety glasses, goggles and eye guards.

To specifically prevent injuries in baseball, batting helmets can be fitted with protective face guards and fielders can wear safety-certified sports goggles.

Many people don’t realize  that prescription glasses (and sunglasses) worn during play not only don’t offer protection, but they increase the risk of eye injury. Street eyeglasses and contacts can easily shatter upon impact and puncture the eye and surrounding areas.  Athletes who wear glasses or contacts can usually have their prescriptions matched in protective eyewear.

Return to Play

In order to return to play following an eye injury, the eye should be pain free, cause no discomfort and vision returned to normal. Release by an ophthalmologist should be required before an player with a serious eye injury returns to play. The team physician or athletic trainer should be able to determine if and when players with less serious eye injuries can return. Athletes returning to play following an eye injury should be required to wear eye protection to avoid a second injury.


Source: “Baseball Ranks #1 in Sports-related Eye Injuries for Kids.”.  www.digitaljournal.com. 14 April, 2016.